I didn't do this research but I found it and want to share it:

Excellent/Very Good =

PVL whey Gourmet Peanut butter and chocolate

About Time Chocolate

Champion Pure Whey Stack Chocolate mixed with IDS vanilla Cinnamon (by Vitalady.com)

Chike banana Magic

Dynamize Elite Pina Colada

Gaspari's MyoFusion Banana Perfection

IDS Multi-Pro Whey Belgian Chocolate

IDS Multi-Pro Whey Isolate Vanilla Cinnamon

Lean Dessert Banana Nut Bread

Lean Dessert Banana Cream pudding

Lean Dessert Chocolate Coconut Candy Bar

Lean Dessert Chocolate Fudge Pudding

Syntrax nectar Fuzzy Peach

Syntrax Nectar Sweets Chocolate Truffle

Syntrax Nectar Twisted Cherry

powders?utm_source=BariatricPal&utm_medium=Affiliate&utm_campaign=CommentLink" target="_ad" data-id="1" >unjury chicken Soup

Good =

4 Ever Fit Fruit Blast Cranrazz

About Time Birthday Cake

Allmax Isoflex Chocolate Mint

Allmax Isoflex Peanut Butter Chocolate

Champion Pure Whey Stack Cookies and Cream

Champion Pure Whey Stack Tropical Sunrise

Designer Whey Chocolate Peanut Caramel

Designer Whey strawberry

Dymatize Elite Orange Dreamsicle (in Water... I bet it'd be even better with soymilk blended with ice)

Dymatize Elite Rich Chocolate

Gaspari's MyoFusion Chocolate Mint

Gaspari's MyoFusion Milk Chocolate

IDS Multi-Pro Whey Isolate Mixed berry

IDS Multi-Pro Whey Isolate Vanilla Cream

Lean Dessert Whipped Vanilla Cream

Optimum Caramel Toffee Fudge

Syntrax Nectar Chocolate Truffle

Syntrax Nectar Crystal Sky (fruit punch)

Syntrax Nectar Natural Peach

Syntrax Nectar Strawberry Kiwi

Fair/OK =

4 Ever Fit Fruit Blast Tangy Orange

4 Ever Fit Lemon Tea

About Time Strawberry

Allmax Chocolate

Allmax Isoflex Strawberry

Champion Whey Pure Whey Stack Banana Scream

Champion Whey Pure Whey Stack Chocolate

Champion Whey Pure Whey Stack Chocolate Peanut Butter

Champion Whey Pure Whey Stack Cocoa-Mochaccino

Champion Whey Pure Whey Stack Strawberry

Chike Chocolate

Chike Orange Creme

Designer Whey Chocolate

Designer Vanilla Praline

Dymatize Elite Berry Blast

Dymatize Elite Cafe Mocha

Dymatize Elite Chocolate Mint

Dymatize Elite Gourmet Vanilla

Dymatize Elite Smooth Banana

Gaspari's MyoFusion Chocolate Peanut Butter (but when mixed with mocha Click was fantastic!)

Gaspari's MyoFusion Delicious Vanilla

IDS Multi-Pro Whey Isolate Banana

Isopure Dutch Chocolate

Optimum Nutrition Rocky Road (but done with almond milk, could be better with soy)

Optimum Vanilla Ice Cream (boring)

ProBlend Strawberry Twist

ProBlend 55 Alpine Vanilla

ProBlend 55 Mocha Cappuccino

ProComplex Chocolate Ice Cream

Syntrax Nectar Cappuccino

Syntrax Nectar Carribean Cooler

Syntrax Nectar Pink Grapefruit (with water)

Syntrax Nectar Roadside Lemonade (with water)

Syntrax Nectar Strawberry Mousse

Syntrax Nectar Vanilla Bean Torte

Bad/Horrible/Nasty =

4 Ever Fit Fruit Blast Raspberry (medicinal... can you say "cough syrup"?)

Designer French Vanilla

Proscore 100 Chocolate

Proscore Vanilla

I just tried two Gotein Protein Supplements. The chocolate was better than most I have tried. However, the Strawberry was positively NASTY!!

I really like ChocoRite brand. I found it much cheaper at netrition.com. With the french vanilla, I use 2 scoops, 8 ounces of water, 2 ounces of skim milk, then when it's allowed, I add about 4 frozen strawberries. When fruit isn't allowed, I use banana flavored sugar free syrup. YUM!!

the BSN lean dessert Banana Cream pudding is good. Orange Chike is really good too. You can get all the BSN flavors at vitacost.com. Free shipping if you order over $49.

If you like your shakes thick like I do, I add a couple tablespoons of

sf instant pudding to my shakes when I want them thicker.

Vitamin Shoppe sells Jay Robb. His is a small container for around $30 so I think it's expensive. BSN is like 14.99

The good deal at Vitamin Shoppe is Pro Pudding by body Tech. It's 145 calories 4 carbs and 25 grams of Protein. only choc and vanilla but it's good pudding!

When visiting my doctor, one of the dieticians said I could mix sugar-free Jello (powdered gelatin) with plain yogurt (she recommended Greek-style). Adds a real nice taste to the yogurt.

Oh Yum. I am definitely going to try that!

I just threw out my Syntrax tubs. I can't stand them anymore. Too "foamy"

I am currently addicted to Bariatric Advantage Orange Cream and the Banana. I think Orange Cream blended with ice cubes tastes like the original Orange Julius. I also add in a frozen banana. I add frozen strawberries into the banana flavor. This is my breakfast everyday. I have never been a breakfast eater, so this works for me.

I was interested in the "PVL Whey Gourmet Peanut butter and chocolate" but when I tried to order last night it was restricted for shipping. Has anyone else run into this problem and do they still sell in GNC stores? The company is in Canada so maybe because of the peanut butter there is a shipping restriction? GNC said they would get back to me after research as to why. Anyone else run into this?

The only place I have ever gotten PVL Whey Gourmet is at netrition.com

I get Gaspari Myofusion peanut butter/chocolate at

vitacost.com .Their shipping is free if you order over $49 which is easy to do. they have everything. It's not as expensive as PVL because it's a 5 lb tub not a 2 lb tub.

Has anyone tried Body Fortress Whey? It comes in Chocolate, Vanilla and Strawberry. I just bought some unflavored stuff the other day...but post op I don't know what I can add to it...it wasn't a well thought out plan lol.

I found Body Fortress to be quite good. I buy most of my Protein powders in vanilla as you can add liquid/powder flavoring agents or frozen fruits. Right now I'm using Six Star from Walmart. Vanilla Creme flavor. Tastes real good.

I ordered the sample pack from Syntax, but have only tried a few. Yesterday I made a drink with the Caribbean Cooler pack & Water. It separates from water to easily. Had to keep shaking the cup to keep the contents mixed. The taste was OK, but I wouldn't buy a tub of it.

I have tried Chocolate Frost and Strawberry Smash by Twin Labs, and Cookies and Cream by Pure Protein. These were fine before surgery, but now I can't even stand the smell of them. I have tried the chocolate, mixed several diferent ways, and the taste of the powder, over powers everything else. Waiting for some Isopure I ordered. I ordered Alpine Punch and Mango Peach. We'll see how that turns out. Also, has anyone tried the PB2 yet. It's a powdered peanut butter that was featured on the Dr. Oz show. Only adds a small amount of protein, but is delicious. I have some unflavored powder by Now Sports. I mixed a scoop of the protein, 8 oz. of Chocolate Silk Light, and 2 tblsp. PB2., and it was delish!

ok, i got my Isopure. YUCK!!!!! I thought maybe if I just diluted it I could drink it, but it made it worse. Also, tried making my own protein shot, using a scoop and 1/4 cup of water. It came back up faster than it went down.

I have started my own notebook documenting experiences with different ones. I'll share it when I get further along.

Ok, This is something I really struggled with post surgery, so I am gonna keep posting every time I try something new,lol I got some samples from Bj's bariatrics of the Syntrax Nectars. So far I have tried the Cappucino and the Double Stuffed Cookie and both are great!!

I have been using the protein powder from walmart , i think, Pure Protein, frosty chocolate(25 grams protein) and Body Fortress, french vanilla(26 grams protein). Well, we got some premixed Atkins Advantage shakes with only 15 grams of protein. Well, I like them but I swear I have been more hungry since I tried them, only yesterday. Plus, I have to take in an extra shake to get the amt of protein. What do you all think of the Atkins Advantage shakes? Are they a big no no??

There is nothing wrong with Atkins drinks. Like you said, they are lower in protein than some of the other drinks, but if you like them, I wouldn't worry about drinking an extra one. If you're on the post op liquid stage, you can't be consuming many

calories anyway.