Should I convert from my Lap Band, to the Gastric Sleeve? My band has slipped and not restricting!


16 posts in this topic

I'm looking for folks that have had their lap band converted to a gastric sleeve.

I'm on my 2nd band. 1st banded in 1999 with a Swedish band in Monterrey, Mexico. 2nd band in U.S. in 2006. 2nd band has now "slipped", so says the doctor. I'm not feeling restriction, even though it is filled and little is passing through. I've gained 30 pounds since December, and getting scared.

I'm looking into going to Dr. Ortiz in Tijuana for a conversion (cash pay- no insurance coverage). However, I have no idea what going to a gastric sleeve will be like in comparison to the band. With the band, I had a lot of restriction, and so, wasn't able to eat much. If I eat over 1,000 calories a day, I gain weight. And I do exercise diligently.

Any feedback of your conversion experience would be appreciated. Especially, how the sleeve feels in comparison to the band- eating food wise.

Thank you!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In my opinion, YES. I switched from band to sleeve three years ago and it was the best decision ever.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am almost 2 months out. I had a band from 2008 until 2013... successful with it - lost 120 pounds and kept 100 off through out having it... then it just shut down- no slip or erosion - dr said scar tissue- took it out and well old habits crept back in. 4 years later~ sleeve...So my experience with the sleeve is that full is a completely different feeling and that restriction is an understatement- I can't eat more than 1/3 cup of anything- even slider foods... i average 400-500 calories a day - you have to chew everything! I stick to a low carb diet- so 2 months out my typical day is either a Protein Shake or 1 scrambled egg around 8 am, okios triple zero yogurt for my second meal around 11am, around 2 pm I may eat a boiled egg (deviled with mayo and mustard) around 4pm a tuna packet and around 8pm if I'm hungry- another Protein Drink or yogurt. Sometimes I will go through Chick-fil-A and get the 8 count grilled nuggets but can only eat 4... save the others for lunch the next day.... not sure if that helps- I am personally happy I did it. I can eat 1/8 of a slice of thin crust Red Barron pizza and stop! (I use to eat the whole thing) I am down 35 pounds from surgery and 45 pounds since starting the process again...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, thank you so much for all this information! This is exactly what I was looking for!

The band restricted me from eating so well, that I was successful in losing and keeping off the weight. But I was worried that the sleeve wouldn't offer the same feeling of restriction, and that I would be able to eat a lot more. Knowing that I can eat so few calories a day without gaining, has made me very worried about converting.

So thank you again for your feedback, and I do wish you all the best! If I can ever be of any help to you, please let me know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had conversion from Lapband to sleeve exactly four months ago and it has been awesome! I lost very little weight with the band and put it all back on. I gave it five years, but it just did not work for me. I can't speak highly enough for the sleeve right now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for your input! May I ask, did you not have restriction with the band, is that the reason you didn't feel it worked? Can you please comment if this prevents you from eating so much at one time? Or do you eat less because of less hunger hormone? Do you FEEL less hungry, as the doctors are saying will happen because there is less hunger hormone? Thank you!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm on my second band and planning to move to sleeve. I had the Swedish 4cc band in 2004 and lost 100 lbs easily. It kept leaking - first the tube, then the port. Only gained 20 lbs back and managed to get monthly fills for years that kept emptying but it kept the weight at bay at least. Finally got the port fixed and then got pregnant and boom - the band totally disconnected. When they replaced the band I never got back to that sweet spot and it slips all the time. It's unfilled right now and I cough constantly if I eat more than a cup of food. Cough until I puke. At work. In meetings. But I'm full on hungry with growling and all the old food lust back. Badly slipped. I'm so disappointed.

Anyway it's getting removed next week thank god and then I am appealing the insurance denial for a revision. Worst case is that I will switch insurance in November then start the sleeve process. I'm unable to be consistent with food when I'm alone with it without some kind of tool, I accept it about myself. I'm hanging on by my fingernails waiting for all these events to unfold. I'm up another 40 lbs from my lowest to a total of 60 lb gain. Reading these stories keeps me going!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm 6 days post-op from a band to sleeve revision in Mexico with Dr Gutierrez. I had the band for 1 1/2 years. Same thing happened to me. Which is nothing. By one year it was completely full but I felt no restrictions. Ever. I lost about 25 pounds out of own will and work. My surgeon wanted to go in and reposition the band up higher on my stomach to shrink the pouch. But that would have cost almost as much as a sleeve surgery. I didn't want to spend another fortune to fix something that may not work again. So we decided on a sleeve. And in Mexico. My surgeon here at home actually recommended Mexico. I feel good. I really feel better after this surgery than the band. I have had no pain, nausea, etc. It's been great really. I know it's still early, but I'm hopeful.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N920A using BariatricPal mobile app

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have my lap band removal at the end of this month. I met with my surgeon again today. I can't wait to get the sleeve in 3 months. I had some anxiety, but, he calmed my nerves.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Featured Surgeons

    1. David C Voellinger

      Charlotte, NC 28105
      704-316-7760

    2. Dmitri V. Baranov

      Saratoga Springs, NY 12866
      855-344-8555

  • Recent Topics

  • Recent Status Updates

    • Thejeweledsleeve

      Sorry I am sooo late. I will make it short and quick.
      6/15 - Keto nothing out of the ordinary. 
      6/16 - Gym and healthy eating. 
      6/17 - I had a small I mean baby spoon of Red Velvet cake for my b-day and I was out for the count. I had to use the bathroom a lot. My mom said, "uh hmmm. was it worth it?". I whispered, " Yes" lol. Just an overall bad day. I broke the diet and ate carbs and sugar. Shame Shame !!!! Lol I am only Human.
      6/18 - The cake was still messing with me so I barely ate or even drank water. I was exhausted all day. Weighed in at 209.8 lbs.
      1-Month Post Op Overall Loss: 14.6
      2-Month Post Op Overall Loss: 8.8 lbs
      3-Month Post Op overall loss: 10.8 lbs
      6/19 - Barely ate or drank water again. I just slept most of the day away. Spent a lot of time in the bathroom. 
      6/20 - Still followed the Keto Diet.
      6/21 - Still followed the Keto Diet. Still time, adding breakfast foods to the option instead of a shake or protein shot. 
      6/22 - Breakfast: Baked Turkey Bacon (3 Slices), 1 Egg white. 1 Romaine Lettuce leaf. 
      Snack: 14 Olives
      Lunch: 2 oz of ground chicken, mild salsa, 1 tsp of sour cream, and 1 romaine lettuce leaf.
      Snack: Sugar Free Popsicle. 
      Dinner: 2 oz of ground chicken, mild salsa, 1 tsp of sour cream, and 1 romaine lettuce leaf.
      Snack: 1 pickle
      6/23 - Breakfast: 3 Egg Whites
      Lunch: Homemade Chicken Salad - no dressing. 
      Dinner: Pickles and Sugar Free Popsicle. 
      6/24 - Went to a friends baby shower. They actually had healthier food options. Met a few of her extended family whom had Bariatric Surgery. One woman (weighing 392 lbs) had the bypass 17 years ago. She said back then there was not a pysch eval, waiting period or even a pre-authorization. She said she went to the doctor Monday and that Thursday she had the surgery. She showed me all the scars from access skin removal. She told me that nothing prepares you for the disappointment you will feel when you work hard and you do not look the way you thought. She had to have a full body lift and breast augmentation. It was soo enlightened to speak with someone whom was from that time and had the experience. She told me that sugar kills her but rice and bread is her fave. She stated that she got down to 125 lbs and felt soo unattractive. She stated that she gained her weight back up to 185 lbs and have maintained that weight for over 10 years. 
      6/25 - Had my Keto Meal. 
      Breakfast: Baked Turkey Bacon (3 Slices), 1 Boiled Egg white. 
      Snack: 14 Olives
      Lunch: 2 oz of chicken, 1 tsp of sour cream, and 2 romaine lettuce leaf.
      Snack: Sugar Free Popsicle. 
      Dinner: 2 oz of Chicken and Romaine Lettuce with 1/2 tomato. 
      Snack: 1 pickle
      My best friend is trying to get me to try Isagenix (https://www.isagenix.com/en-us/products/weight-loss). She has lost 55 lbs since February on it. It is like $378 a month. I am like the hell!! Bro whom has that money. She is really excited and she wants to me to try it so bad. I am tempted. Keto has been awesome but I am bored now and want to try something else. I think I am a Fad Diet Groupie. 
      Oh and the Hydrate. On the days when I focus on water. I am barely eating. I love those days. Food does not be on my mind. Below I have screen shot my progress. So yayy. Keto has really helped me get back on track. 

      · 1 reply
      1. Newme17

        Happy belated birthday!!!! 🎉🎈🎁 too bad the bite of cake didn't sit well either. It was interesting reading about the process of the bypass 17 years ago. I think today's way is better, but man, that would be awesome too, not having to do all the hoops then.

        I think you should tell your friend NO to the diet. First, it's a fad. Second, it's way expensive! Stick to your sleeve hon. You've got a lot to work with right now anyway. But you really do need to find what you will stick to that is healthy for you and not be bored with for the rest of your life. It can take some tries....it just has to be sustainable for you.

        I have been slacking with the Hydrate. Picking it back up tomorrow. Do you put ice in yours?

    • pfisher

      What an emotional roller coaster these past few days have been! Lost my job Friday and have been battling to maintain some sense of a normal routine. I haven't kept up my walking routine and have been nibbling food since yesterday. Thankful for the support of my husband who is reminding me that this is the opportunity I've needed to find the job I'm passionate about. Haven't discussed this with the kids at this point and my daughter is already planning "an extra long walk" for tomorrow for the both of us.
      Prayers, positive vibes, and kind thoughts/suggestions welcome as I navigate the job market at my age!
      Back on track tomorrow!!!
      · 0 replies
      1. This update has no replies.
    • Mickel

      Just now have released my newest video on Youtube called VSG 101 - History, Evolution, & Cost.  Hope you let me know if you like it or not!
       
      · 0 replies
      1. This update has no replies.
    • Jeffrey Stern

      So a while back I was asking about eating nuts for snack and got a good response . Then I came upon an article (now anything I read on line I take with a grain of salt) that does say eating certain nuts is good for the waist line. eg. Almonds,cashews and walnuts. This article also lists other foods that will help in that field such as tomatoes,oatmeal,meat/fish,eggs,olive oil,broccoli,avocado,berries,hot peppers, spinach and lastly green tea. I can honestly say I eat all these items and are mainly my daily diet...but the hot peppers. I would direct you to the site but can't find it. sorry
      any feed back ??
      · 1 reply
      1. Newme17

        Did you know a jalapeño has more vitamin c than 18 oranges??? A bunch of the older generation of a certain culture here eat jalapeños with their food, on the side! I love them too, but sometimes they can be bad for those who have acid reflux too/heartburn. Overall, they can be good for you.

        Those are all great foods to incorporate in a healthy diet. Berries for the antioxidants. Oatmeal for fiber. Olive oil and avocado for fats. Spinach and broccoli for iron and fiber. I've got to get in the habit of green tea though.....

    • laeashanicole  »  Ellemarie0708

      Hello, I was reviewing the thread and see that we have the same surgery date. Hopefully, we can keep in touch! Good Luck!
      · 0 replies
      1. This update has no replies.
  • Trending Topics

  • Magazine Articles

    1. Get Your Grill On!

      Posted in: Food & Nutrition
      Rene Norman, RD/LD
    2. 3 Ways to Break Through a Plateau

      Posted in: Plateaus and Regain
      Katy Harvey, MS, RD, LD, CEDRD
    3. How I Conquered My 20th High School Reunion

      Posted in: Body Image
      Nanette Adams, M.Ed., LPC
    4. Lose Weight without Surgery

      Posted in: Pre-Op Support
      My Bariatric Life
    5. Food Addiction: FAIR and FIRM Video (Part 2)

      Posted in: Food & Nutrition
      Connie Stapleton, PhD
  • Together, we have lost...
      lbs