Which surgeon did you choose?

dietpeach · August 11, 2008

Dr. Ren, Fielding, or Kurian?

wsw27 · August 12, 2008

Dr. Kurian did my surgery. She is terrifc. From everything I've read, all three are top notch. I think you might have a longer wait for Fielding and Ren. Also, each one accepts different insurance, so you may not really have a choice unless you are self-pay. I met with the nutritionist, the nurse and Dr. Kurian on the same day. (I think you have to make a separate appt to meet the surgeon if you plan to have Ren or Fielding do the surgery). I met with Dr. Kurian mid -May and my surgery date was July 1, 2008. I think 6 weeks is typical. I will say that the process for insurance approval is a stressful as my paperwork was submitted less than one week before my surgery date even though the paperwork was complete several weeks earlier. The person who does the insurance approvals is overworked and can be short. I found email was the best way to reach her. Hope this helps. Good luck to you.

dietpeach · August 12, 2008

Thank you Wendy, that was very informative. I'm still far away from getting a date and all that, but could you tell me the name and email of the person I need to contact when my papers are submitted? That could save me a few weeks. (I'm desperate to get banded already.)

Also, is it allowed to schedule my consultation if I haven;t met the nutritionist yet? I'm probably going to go with Dr. Fielding.

Thanks again, your reply was very helpful.

LadyWinsAll · August 13, 2008

Thank you Wendy, that was very informative. I'm still far away from getting a date and all that, but could you tell me the name and email of the person I need to contact when my papers are submitted? That could save me a few weeks. (I'm desperate to get banded already.)
Also, is it allowed to schedule my consultation if I haven;t met the nutritionist yet? I'm probably going to go with Dr. Fielding.

Thanks again, your reply was very helpful.

Hi:

You can get all your visits scheduled on the same day. They do try to do so if possible and yes, you have a longer wait for Drs. Fielding and Ren-Fielding. Nilsa is Dr. Kurian's patient coordinator and Asia is Dr. Ren's. Nilsa is extremely overworked but competent. Asia is sweet and helpful but she is new and not as seasoned as Nilsa.

:whatchutalkingabout

NYCFun · August 29, 2008

Wsw27 - thanks for that tidbit of information. I'm meeting with Dr. Kurian in a little over a week, but I have no idea if she's the one who accepts my insurance. I'll have to give the office a call and see.

Chrisann · September 3, 2008

I didn't like my impression of Dr. Kurian the first time I saw her at the seminar. I also didn't care for some of the speakers. If my Primary care doctor wasn't so confident in NYU, I probably would have looked elsewhere. Then when he did the referral, I didn't even need one for my insurance, he listed Dr. Ren. So I stuck with her.

I am so happy with her and my after care that I would do it all over again.

sim78 · September 7, 2008

I decided to go with Dr Fielding since my workmate who did the sugery told me that I would like his personality and she was right. My husband is doing it with Dr. Ren and he is happy with his choice. I am having my surgery a whole month earlier then him basically since he has medical things that I don't have to worry about. Like he has a cut that has to heal and he has to go for the sleep study. I can't wait till my surgery!!!