First Nutritionist Appt Yesterday -- Surprises

[DanaInNewOrleans 513]

First nutritionist appointment yesterday -- she was very nice and informative however she said something that kind of took me by surprise. She was looking at my stats -- weight, BMI....

She says ok, "lets see, you have one year to get 100 pounds off". I said yeah, that would be great. Then she says ." you only have a year to do this. This doesn't go on indefinitely, you only have about a year. After that, pretty much where you are is where you are going to stay". I must have had a surprised look on my face because she said again, kind of scolding --- "Yes, you have about a year do get off as much as you can because after that is where you'll stay".

That is not the impression I've gotten from VST. I would say, yes, the majority of people lose the majority of their weight in the first year-- that makes sense, but there are many that are still losing after a year. Right?

She was also very dramatic when I mentioned I was dreading the pureed/mushy. She said. "we're not doing anything to your teeth -- YOU CHEW" I do not want you pureeing food and only eating mush. I want you to CHEW your food until it is soft. And I DO NOT want you eating baby food, for Gods sake. All these people come here and say their pureering food - ridiculous! They need to use their teeth!"

Thoughts?

Dana

[traceyc 89]

I thought the pureeing was so we didn't accidentally swallow something too big and hurt our healing stomachs. There seems to be a huge difference in the diets and nutritionist. I don't think it would hurt if you wanted to do purees for awhile. I know I couldn't chew up my food enough to feel comfortable for weeks. How long is your liquid phase? Maybe if they do a longer liquid phase they skip pureed?

I haven't heard of the where you are at a year is where you will stay. I think there are people on here who took longer than a year to get to their goal. Sure it is faster at first but I think if you diet and exercise you can keep loosing weight after a year.

[Tammy310 43]

I was told that the stages: clear liquid, full liquid, puree, soft, regular are all stages designed to help us adjust to our new stomachs. Additionally, as TraceyC stated, it helps us heal so that we don't accidentally cause any undue damage. It sounds as though your NUT has some preformed opinions and perhaps you should take that info back to the surgeon. Also, might I suggest switching to a different NUT...much like any counselor you should find someone that you can mesh well with. That way they can help you post-op too.

Good luck.

[Catracks 865]

I just ate food that was naturally that way during the pureed/soft food stage like refried Beans, hummus, cottage cheese, blended Soups, etc. There is plenty of time later for chewing. It's not like you'll get out of the habit.

Also, the bit about only having a year is BS! As you get closer to goal, it is harder to lose, but you can lose weight at any time like anyone else, plus you have the sleeve as a tool. Their is no magic that halts you at a year just as there is no magic that says we can only lose 60% of our excess weight.

You're right. It takes many people longer than a year to reach goal. I have spoken to them here. It's just that some people tend to fall back into old habits. All of that is entirely up to you.

[Robyn Owens-Miille 132]

I was told "majority" of the weight comes off at the beginning but not that it completely stops or becomes impossible (but 100 pounds over 52 weeks is very reasonable).

Also, my doc absolutely INSISTS on the puree stage with absolutely NO LUMPS. He is adamant about you not damaging your sleeve. Says you must puree it before it goes into your mouth.

[IsB 209]

The medical field is full of generalities. They love to gather up tons of data and talk averages and percentages. That doesn't mean you can't keep losing after a year and it also doesn't mean that if you have bad habits you'll keep losing after 6 months. There are lots of people able to lose tremendous amounts of weight without surgery but these bariatric surgeons like to make it sound like it's impossible.

It's your body and your health. Don't let someone else stop you from achieving your goals.

[Butterthebean 8,146]

I wasn't required to have a "puréed" food stage, just soft foods. I went from full liquids to scrambled eggs and finely ground chili. No problems.

[gustavo52974 369]

Yeesh. Your NUT sounds like real jerk. You have to use your teeth? That's preposterous. Your teeth won't fall out if you don't use them, at least during a puréed food stage.

And I've never heard that you have one year. That doesn't sound logical. I'll ask my surgeon about that but I bet he'll just laugh.

[Tammy310 43]

on the 1 year: My doc says that 60% of the weight loss occurs in the first 6mos. However, he didn't cap it to a year. He just said, "get up and move (exercise), eat right (protein & vitamins), and drink drink drink (water~not alcohol)" the rest will take care of itself.

I love my doc.

[Butterthebean 8,146]

Yeesh. Your NUT sounds like real jerk. You have to use your teeth? That's preposterous. Your teeth won't fall out if you don't use them' date=' at least during a puréed food stage.

And I've never heard that you have one year. That doesn't sound logical. I'll ask my surgeon about that but I bet he'll just laugh.[/quote']

The "one year" is just a window of time where the weight loss is the easiest. It is certainly ideal to focus on getting to goal during that year, but it isn't absolutely necessary. My Dr called it the honeymoon stage. He said take advantage of it, because once it's over....it's over. But to say you can never lose a pound after that is ridiculous.

[xlr8ahead 40]

First nutritionist appointment yesterday -- she was very nice and informative however she said something that kind of took me by surprise. She was looking at my stats -- weight' date=' BMI....

She says ok, "lets see, you have one year to get 100 pounds off". I said yeah, that would be great. Then she says ." you only have a year to do this. This doesn't go on indefinitely, you only have about a year. After that, pretty much where you are is where you are going to stay". I must have had a surprised look on my face because she said again, kind of scolding --- "Yes, you have about a year do get off as much as you can because after that is where you'll stay".

That is not the impression I've gotten from VST. I would say, yes, the majority of people lose the majority of their weight in the first year-- that makes sense, but there are many that are still losing after a year. Right?

She was also very dramatic when I mentioned I was dreading the pureed/mushy. She said. "we're not doing anything to your teeth -- YOU CHEW" I do not want you pureeing food and only eating mush. I want you to CHEW your food until it is soft. And I DO NOT want you eating baby food, for Gods sake. All these people come here and say their pureering food - ridiculous! They need to use their teeth!"

Thoughts?

Dana[/quote']

I think u need a new nutritionist.one with a more possitive attitude. lol .u only have to go on this site to see shes full of s... She prob a bit over weight .and is gutted that she cant have it done lol.

[xlr8ahead 40]

I think u need a new nutritionist.one with a more possitive attitude. lol .u only have to go on this site to see shes full of s... She prob a bit over weight .and is gutted that she cant have it done lol.

[xlr8ahead 40]

Hi alex dont really know how to send things on here.but il try it.i would like to say thank u.im so glad I found this forum.id be lost with out it.

[DanaInNewOrleans 513]

The "one year" is just a window of time where the weight loss is the easiest. It is certainly ideal to focus on getting to goal during that year, but it isn't absolutely necessary. My Dr called it the honeymoon stage. He said take advantage of it, because once it's over....it's over. But to say you can never lose a pound after that is ridiculous.

This is definitely what she meant but my question to her (which she didn't really address) was what about the people who have to lose say 200 pounds -- is it reasonable to think they will lose 200 pounds in one year? I'm sure weight loss continues. I didn't mean to imply that I thought she meant," ok, year is over, you're done" I just was surprised that she came at it from almost a negative position instead of saying, hey the first year is where you will have the most success so lets make sure you get the most bang for your buck.

[DanaInNewOrleans 513]

I think u need a new nutritionist.one with a more possitive attitude. lol .u only have to go on this site to see shes full of s... She prob a bit over weight .and is gutted that she cant have it done lol.

lol... guess what? You're right! She is overweight!