Jump to content
×
Are you looking for the BariatricPal Store? Go now!

VSG vs RNY hard decision very confused :(



Recommended Posts

So I had my first appointment with Dr. Choi at Montifiore Hospital on December 20th and I must say I felt real comfortable with her. She's a great surgeon and has great feed back. Only thing that really made me sad was when she asked me with surgery I was looking into to get. I said VSG of course! Lol and she said she Doesn't recommend VSG for anyone with really bad Acid Reflux and a Hiatal hernia which would be repaired but she said might return in about 5 years. Bummer!!!! I really was looking into vSG and now this whole thing puts everyone on to another path.. Has anyone had a hiatal hernia repaired and or acid reflux and has had VSG? I need some advice !! She says she Would be happy to do either surgery , but i just have to know that there would be a risk of my reflux returning and being much worse then before surgery.. That would put me on Iron , Calcium and antacid medicine for the rest of my life! Help!!!! Lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why not get the vertical sleeve surgery first and if it is too bad to tolerate then get the gastric bypass. That's the beauty of the vertical sleeve, you can get it changed to a bypass.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've seen people on this site that had the sleeve and had the hernia repaired at the same time. In fact there is a youtube video on that. I have acid reflux, but i'm not letting that stop me. Plus my surgeon says I can continue taking omeprazole, or if that doesn't work anymore I could try something else.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The best advice I can give is find a surgeon that your happy with (read trust) and take their advice.

I met with 3 surgeons before I went ahead. I would follow what ever advice my guy gave.

Good luck,

Deano

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, my husband was the one sleeved, on 10-19-2012. He didn't have acid reflux before, but now has a severe case. Even had an Upper GI done yesterday because we didn't know what had been causing the nausea and gagging/throwing up. Will be so glad to see him feel better. He's lost 85 pounds since the beginning of the pre-op diet and I want him to enjoy the loss. He only regrets now. He's been taking Prilosec for months, as a preventative from earlier surgeries, but not working. They prescribed Protonix this morning. I've heard good things about it. He did also have a large hernia repair done at the same time.

I too was all set to be sleeved after my insurance required 6 month wait. 1st, my insurance will only pay towards the band or the bypass. I'm not doing the band. I do have occasional reflux so thinking maybe the sleeve isn't a good idea for me anyway. Looking forward to learning alot here. :)

Debbie

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Unfortunately this is just something you need to research and decide for yourself. The reality is that any examples you find here are most likely to be folks that chose VSG - this is VST, after all! Many of us are a bit biased because we chose this surgery over the other options.

It's also impossible to say how your body would react afterward. I have read both positives and negatives about reflux post op. While just about everyone is on a PPI for some period of time in the first year post op, the vast majority of us are off of them by the time we reach one year. That doesn't mean everyone is, though. I've seen a handful of posts from people that continue to take meds years post op, and yes, even posts like the one from Debbie - where someone has a very serious issue with reflux that requires prescription meds.

I think the hernia is less of a concern as I've read a huge number of stories about hernia repair being done with the sleeve and I've never once read a complication or recurrence post. But you'll need to do your own research on this one.

I have a dear friend that opted for RNY recently. She lost 220 pounds and reached her goal within 14 months. She looks amazing and for her, the RNY was a better option for a few reasons. One, she had a very significant amount of weight to lose, and while VSG could have gotten her there the journey would have been much slower. Two, her insurance covered RNY and didn't cover VSG, so that was a no-brainer in her case. And perhaps most importantly to her, there are far more RNY surgeons and support groups where she lives - she needed a weekly meeting to help her through the surgery and it isn't always easy to find in person support because the VSG really is a newer surgery with less surgeons and patients. That's why VST is such a thriving community. I know a number of WLS patients in real life and only one of them has had the sleeve!

There are very serious things to consider besides hernias and reflux. The RNY means a lifetime of supplements and testing, while the period we need these things with VSG is far shorter and many people never experience long term deficiencies. You also need to consider the cause of your obesity. Are you a habitual overeater? Be aware that a pouch does stretch over time, and therefore your lifetime diet requires more diligence on your part. The sleeve has very little give and is far more difficult to stretch. If you want malabsorption, the RNY is a better choice, but you should not count on this benefit beyond the first year. Again, do your research and read as many real stories, both positive and negative, as you can.

However, there is no denying that people have had great success with both surgeries. You'll need to weigh the pros and cons and perhaps get a second opinion before you make this choice.

In the end, your chosen surgery is just a tool. People say that over and over again but it is absolutely true and it's something you won't truly understand until you're post op and living your new life. There are failures and regains with every WLS out there. Many of the same issues will need to be addressed regardless of what you choose. You will need to learn to eat properly, to use moderation, to stop overeating, to stop emotional food triggers, etc. The burden is really on you to learn to use the tool for long term success, and in my opinion, either option can be perfectly successful if you work hard enough.

Good luck whatever you decide.

~Cheri

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My surgeon won't do VSG on patients with reflux either but I never had a problem with reflux before surgery or after do far

Sent from my iPhone using VST

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks so much for all your advices! I'm still leaning more towards VSG. I know that it's still a new surgery but for some reason I feel it's much more safer and less risks after surgery. Reflux can always be treated with antacids or PPIs . I myself do not like medicine but I guess I have to test and see which antacid will work for me. I have my first nutritionist appointment on the 30th of this month. My doctor said 4 visits and then she would send me to get my pre-operative testing and then we can talk about which surgery I've decided on. Hopefully VSG will me my first & final decision. Prayers! Prayers! That's all I will need! Thanks all! Best of luck to all of you in your journey! ❤

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had the sleeve and hiatal hernia repair on 12/27. I've actually noticed a decrease in my reflux.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You can always get a bypass and insurance will cover it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Trending Products

  • Trending Topics

  • Recent Status Updates

    • vsg.with.sharon

      Hey everyone!
      I’m new here! Looking for some friends! 🥰
      · 0 replies
      1. This update has no replies.
    • LeighaTR

      Four days post surgery. I am sipping as fast as I can and getting NO WHERE near the goal of 60 - 80 grams of protein or the 64 oz of liquids. I just feel FULL. I don't know if it can still be the gas build up (I would think by now that would be gone) but it is a struggle to drink. And so far I have not had the nausea or spasms and don't want to wander into that territory by pushing too hard with liquids. I about passed out today as it was my most "strenuous" day. Went from second story to basement for shower and I was sure I was going to pass out. Looking back on my last few days I have had a total of less than 1000 calories. Am I just not getting enough nourishment in me? Once again a friday where I can't get ahold of the doc until Monday rolls back around so I am hoping maybe someone here has some experience on how to keep energy going. I do have fibromyalgia too and that may be where some added fatigue comes into play. How did you all fair with the goals the week after surgery?
      · 0 replies
      1. This update has no replies.
    • Doughgurl

      2 days until I fly out to San Diego to have my Bypass Surg. in Tiajuana Mexico. Not gonna lie, the nerves are starting to surface. I don't fear the surgery itself, or the fact that I'm traveling alone, but its the aftermath that I'm stressing about the most, after this 8 week wait. I'm excited to finally be here, but I am really dreading the post surgical chapter. I know its going to be tough, real tough and I think I'm just in my head to much now that the day i here. Wish me luck, Hopefully I'm one of the lucky ones, and everything goes smoothly. Cant wait to give an exciting update,. If there is anyone else have a June bypass or even a recent one, Id love to have someone to compare war stories with. Also, anyone near San Antonio Tx? See ya soon with the future me. 💜
      · 3 replies
      1. Phil Penn

        Good Luck this procedure is well worth it I am down to 249.6 lb please continue with the process..

      2. Selina333

        I'm in Houston so kind of near you and had the sleeve in Dec. Down 61 lbs. Feeling better. Was definitely worth it. I hope the everything is going well for you. Update us when you can!

      3. Doughgurl

        I am back home after my bypass surgery in Tiajuana. I'm post op day 4. Everything went great! I guess I'm one of the lucky ones who have not encountered much pain at all, no nausea thus far and I'm having no problem keeping down broths and water. Thank you for your well wishes. I cant wait to keep up this journey and have a chance at better health and simply better quality of life. I know there will be bumps in the road ahead, and everything won't be peaches and cream, but at least I have a great start so far. 😍

    • LeighaTR

      I am new here today... and only two weeks out from my sleeve surgery on the 23rd. I am amazed I have kept my calories down to 467 today so far... that leaves me almost 750 left for dinner and maybe a snack. This is going to be tough for two weeks... but I have to believe I can do it!
      · 0 replies
      1. This update has no replies.
    • Doughgurl

      Hey everyone. I'm new here so I thought I should introduce myself. I am 53y/o and am scheduled for Gastric Bypass on June 25th, 2025. I'm located in San Antonio, Texas. I will be having my surgery in Tiajuana Mexico. I've wanted this for years, but I always had insurance where bariatric procedures were excluded. Finally I am able to afford to pay out of pocket.  I can't wait to get started, and I hope I'm prepared for the initial period of "hell". I know what I have signed up for, but I'm sure the good to come will out way the temporary period of discomfort and feelings of regret. I'd love to find people to talk to who have been through the same procedure or experience before. So I look forward to meeting you all. Hope you have a great week!
      · 2 replies
      1. Selina333

        I'm so happy for you! You are about to change your life. I was so glad to get the sleeve done in Dec. I didn't have feelings of regret overall. And I'm down almost 60 lbs. I do feel a little sad at restaurants. I can barely eat half a kid's meal. I get adults meals often because kid ones don't have the same offerings at times. Then I feel obligated to eat on that until it's gone and that can be days. So the restaurant thing isn't great for me. All the rest is fine by me! I love feeling full with very little. I do wish I could drink when eating. And will sip at the end. Just a strong habit to stop. But I'm working on it! You will do fine! Just keep focused on your desire to be different. Not better or worse. But different. I am happy both ways but my low back doesn't like me that heavy. So I listened (also my feet!). LOL! Update us on your journey! I'm not far from you. I'm in Houston. Good luck and I hope it all goes smoothly! Would love to see pics of the town you go to for this. I've never been there. Neat you will be traveling for this! Enjoy the journey. Take it one day at a time. Sometimes a few hours at a time. Follow all recommendations as best you can. 💗

      2. Doughgurl

        Thank you so much for your well wishes. I am hoping that everything goes easy for me as well. We don't eat out much as it is, so it wont be too bad in that department. Thankfully. Also, I hear you regarding your back and feet!! I'd like to add knees to the list. Killing me as we speak! I'm only 5' so the weight has to go. Too short to carry all this weight. Menopause really did a doosey on me. (😶lol) My daughter also lives in Houston. with her Husband and my 5 grand-littles. I grew up in Beaumont, so I know Houston well, I will be sure to keep in touch and update you on my journey. I may need some advice in the future, or just motivation. Thank You so much for reaching out, I was hoping to connect with someone in the community. I really appreciate it. 💜

  • Recent Topics

  • Hot Products

  • Sign Up For
    Our Newsletter

    Follow us for the latest news
    and special product offers!
  • Together, we have lost...
      lbs

    PatchAid Vitamin Patches

    ×