do you lose more weight with...

[donna12 742]

In your opinion do you lose more weight with lap band with plication than without? Just wondering? My surgeon does not do the plication procedure which now I'm kinda bummed if it speeds up the process, however I'm happy with my weight loss thus far and proud of it because 9 mos ago I could hardly walk, bend over, breathe. This has been a life altering experience, for the better and can only get better as I lose more. I average 3 to 4 lbs a month. I am just now able to exercise, have experienced probs up until now and with weather getting nice here I will be able to get outside and walk at least to start out.

[marfar7 1,533]

I have a minor slip right now and am comtemplating a revision. I think I'm going to talk to my dr about getting the plication with it this time (unavailable in 2009) so I don't have to worry about slips in the future. At least, that what I hear - that it cuts down on slips. Not sure if you lose more weight with it or not, don't know much about it, actually. Good luck tho in finding info!

Marci

[hely88 883]

Everyone is different so there is not really a clear way to answer that question. I have band but have no idea if I would have lost more another way.

[line-dancer 810]

I would think no matter what way you go you still have to eat totally different and keep it that way forever. I have been losing 10 lbs a month which they say is great I am so pleased with it seeing numbers now I cant tell you when I last saw them...keep going you are doing great

[☠carolinagirl☠ 18,722]

my dr told me if i didnt change what i eat, begin to exercise and change my diet mentailty, no WLS surgery would help me......i feel its helped me because i am helping the band and my plication....some are now saying this will (help more)..who knows...depends on the persons level of want power.

[elcee 3,342]

The plication is supposed to mimic the sleeve. That means that it should give you a big "leg up". You shouldn't go through bandster hell as it should give you immediate "restriction".

Just clarify with your surgeon that you are both talking about the same thing when you discuss plication. Many surgeons refer to the way that they stitch a piece of the stomach over the band to stop it slipping as plication.

[DELETE THIS ACCOUNT! 12,703]

I personally believe it doesn't matter which WLS you choose, the speed and success is completely dependant on the person.

You have to remember, none of the WLS make you lose weight. They are all tools to make it easier to consume less calories so you lose weight. This is why people fail, too. They expect magic when they still have to make major lifestyle changes to be successful.

As far as weight loss speed, again it depends on the person more than the WLS of choice. I've lost almost 200 pounds in 14 months, which people would expect from bypass not the band. But, I've done it and did it in a very healthy manner.

Plication is just another tool, like any other WLS surgery.

[donna12 742]

thanks everyone!

[CHEZNOEL 4,061]

I had plicatiion, but I really believe that the results are in each of our hands!