The "What if...?" list is a list of three celebrities that you're "allowed" to cheat on your SO with should the opportunity arise. Jokingly of course. You're allowed to change who's on the list, but you can only have three at any one point so if someone comes into favor, you have to recycle someone else.

So who would be on your list? How about your SO's?

For me it would be Ryan Reynolds, Gary Dourdan, and Brendan Fraser.

For DH it would be Mini Driver, Sarah McLeod (Rosie Cotton in Lord of the Rings), or Billie Piper.

Because only getting three is part of the fun/challenge.

Wentworth Miller

You know - he's going to make my list some day. He's freaking hot.

Ami James from Miami Ink

MMMMM.....he is definately yummy!!!

What a fun question.

1) Hugh Jackman (but only as Wolverine)

2) James Marsters (but only as Spike from Buffy the Vampire Slayer)

3) Karl Urban (Eomer from Lord of the Ringers and Kirill, the assasin, in The Bourne Supremacy. He also played several parts on Xena.)

I don't have a significant other...but I can still fantasize right?

Daniel Craig

Matt Damon

Robert Redford (when he was young)

1. Johnny Depp

2. Tom Brady

3. Sawyer from Lost

DH list:

Sandra Bullock

Carlize Theron (sp?)

Jennifer Aniston

My list:

Jackie Chan

Orlando Bloom

TBA... definately a toss up between Josh Holloway (sawyer from Lost) and Jack from the Simpsons (& LBT)... I love Jack!!!!

I don't have a significant other...but I can still fantasize right?

Daniel Craig

Matt Damon

Robert Redford (when he was young)

I always said if I were sick, I could look at Robert Redford and get well. My all time favorite movie is Out of Africa, but every time I see it, I am so jealous, I want to KILL Meryl Streep.

Nobody else votes for Jimmy Spader? Come on....how can you not love that face?

• Daniel Craig (the "new" James Bond)
  
• Patrick Dempsey (McDreamy on Grey's Anatomy)
  
• Kate Beckingsale (those Underworld suits just get to me :welldone: )

James Spader is definitely hot... and at one time he would have been on my list. Kissable lips.

I just thought of another guy... Blair Underwood. Saw him on the New Adventures of Old Christine tonight... lookin good. But then again, I bet the "real" Jack would knock everyone else off my list... :love:

Who are these people? I only recognize about two names here. I think I'm officially over the hill. Besides sex takes energy and I don't have any.

Who are these people? I only recognize about two names here.

LOL! I'm with you!

I think I'm officially over the hill. Besides sex takes energy and I don't have any.

LOL! I'm NOT with you!

hmmmm....I had to think about this one and I have to say my list is really different....

Vincent D'nofrio (he plays crazy so well and I just think crazy is soooooo sexy....oh I'm so sick.....) :faint:

Trace Atkins (oh my....that body and that VOICE) :cool:

the Rock....okay....no excuse....he is just soooooooooo yum! :welldone:

currently out of my mind....please leave a message....cat

Mine:

Johnny Depp

Matthew Fox (Jack on Lost)

Matthew McConaughey

Boyfriend's:

Natalie Portman

Jennifer Garner

Jennifer Connely

hehe, this thread is fun!

Peyton Manning

Matthew McConaughey/Sawyer (from Lost...toss-up for 2nd)

Ken Watanabe/The Rock (it's a toss-up for 3rd)