The "What if...?" list is a list of three celebrities that you're "allowed" to cheat on your SO with should the opportunity arise. Jokingly of course. You're allowed to change who's on the list, but you can only have three at any one point so if someone comes into favor, you have to recycle someone else.

So who would be on your list? How about your SO's?

For me it would be Ryan Reynolds, Gary Dourdan, and Brendan Fraser.

For DH it would be Mini Driver, Sarah McLeod (Rosie Cotton in Lord of the Rings), or Billie Piper.

#1 Javy Lopez (for sex only - used to catch for the Braves, I love those muscle thighs)

#2 John Travolta (for love - He's been my FAVORITE actor since Vinnie Barbarino and he seems so nice)

#3 is hard - probably Johnny Depp but then it could be about 20 other guys too

Oh my gosh.. I'm a single girl and its definitley hard to narrow down to 3...

Okay..

1. Keith Urban (pre Nicole)

2. Brad Pitt

3. Matthew McConaughey( just watched Failure to Launch last night - His body is awesome!!)

Okay.. throw some cold Water on me, gotta get back to work.

I am single, but my list would be....

1. Johnny Depp

2. Patrick Dempsey

3. Michael Ealy

4. Jay Hernandez (from Crazy Beautiful/Six Degrees)

Demi Morre

Britney Spears

Paris Hilton

Jack from the Simpsons

The only Simpsons I know is the animated show. Surely you're referring to something different? What is it?

Spader is cute but too "pretty boy" for me. Johnny Depp is a "pretty boy" BUT he's so weird that it compensates. Same thing with Leonardo DiCaprio. *shiver - eww - yuck* Way too pretty.

Ryan Gosling is a "pretty boy", but in the Notebook when his hair is all shaggy and he has that shadow of a beard... it's all about YUM!

The only Simpsons I know is the animated show. Surely you're referring to something different? What is it?

Spader is cute but too "pretty boy" for me. Johnny Depp is a "pretty boy" BUT he's so weird that it compensates. Same thing with Leonardo DiCaprio. *shiver - eww - yuck* Way too pretty.

Ryan Gosling is a "pretty boy", but in the Notebook when his hair is all shaggy and he has that shadow of a beard... it's all about YUM!

Oh, but I LOVE pretty boys!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Pretty boys with clean shaven faces....WOW!

Demi Morre

Britney Spears

Paris Hilton

Paris Hilton??????

Three words for you, Saul.....

WEAR A CONDOM!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I attached some images to my picks above. Wanted to make sure that bitteroldhag sees what she's been missing out on!

I guess I'm strange, I don't think Leonardo Dicaprio is cute at all, in fact, he's kinda funny looking to me.

Ditto for Orlando Bloom, maybe its cause they are still babies to me.

I'm not a huge Brad Pitt fan either....except he was a HOTTIE in Troy.

And just about any movie where he has the long hair.

I attached some images to my picks above. Wanted to make sure that bitteroldhag sees what she's been missing out on!

You know.....we need to form a posse and kidnap BOH and take her off to Vegas for a long weekend. Remember....what happens in Vegas, stays in Vegas!

I guess I'm strange, I don't think Leonardo Dicaprio is cute at all, in fact, he's kinda funny looking to me.

Ditto for Orlando Bloom, maybe its cause they are still babies to me.

I'm not a huge Brad Pitt fan either....except he was a HOTTIE in Troy.

And just about any movie where he has the long hair.

Missy....I soooo agree, except about the long hair. Brad Pitt's bare butt was the best thing about Troy!

And I also think Leo is a little weird looking, but a great actor, nonetheless. Orlando Bloom looks like my son-in-law's brother, so that creeps me out too much to think sexy thoughts about him. And he's kind of scruffy looking. I like those smooth baby cheeks!

I'd better get off this thread before someone locks me up for being a dirty old lady!

1. Johnny Depp

2. Tom Brady

3. Sawyer from Lost

How could I have forgotten the Lost guys!? For me it would be Sayid then Sawyer.

Just to be clear, I think Leonardo DiCaprio is creepy, not cute. There are a lot of "mainstream" actors I don't think are cute at all. He's one of them. Brad Pitt is another.

Sometimes there are exceptions to a pretty boy that can make them more desirable, as in the case of Johnny Depp and Ryan Philippe.

I think I prefer men with dorky undertones.

LOL Carlene, You and me both.

[. Brad Pitt's bare butt was the best thing about Troy!

And I also think Leo is a little weird looking, but a great actor, nonetheless. Orlando Bloom looks like my son-in-law's brother, so that creeps me out too much to think sexy thoughts about him. And he's kind of scruffy looking. I like those smooth baby cheeks!

I'd better get off this thread before someone locks me up for being a dirty old lady!

No Way Carlene! I'm loving your posts... don't you dare run away from this thread! I love that you are so.. in the know!

I gotta admit.. I love the pretty boys!! I wish that Keith Urban would shave!

Anybody love Paul Walker and Jon Bon Jovi? Those were the other two that I wanted to put on my list.. YUMMO!