So I went to a seminar for the Lap band and the doctor confused me. He talked about all the WLS available including the Duodenal Switch. He told me that since my BMI was 40.1 that he would do the lap band if I really want it. But then he told me if I want the best results then the duodenal switch. But I don’t know if I want parts of my body cut up, but then I don’t want to get the lap band and not lose any weight. I see so many success stories on here and I want to be one of them. Can some of you please tell me your stories with the lap band and what you went through???? The good and the bad, or if you know any one that has the DS done.

When they say if you want better results, they are talking quicker result. The more extreme surgeries, sleeve and GP, and DS, are all very quick weight loss. However, five years out you will be the same as if you got the band. The band is slower, 1-2lbs a week. This is good in the sense as it doesn't shock your body. It also allows the skin to have a little bit more of a chance to bounce back. The results can be slower and really a bit more frustrating. So make your decision based on how you want your body to react. Just because you get the more extreme surgery doesn't mean that you can't stretch out your stomach later and just gain the weight back either. All the surgeries require a life style change.

Good luck!

Thank you Cangel!!! That is true. I would like my body to lose it slow. That way it is not in so much shock. I notcied you just got the band. How do you like it? Did you lose the 26.5 pounds before the band or since you get banded?

I started off with a pretty high BMI and was never turned away from Lapband. The point is, all WLS require you to change your eating and exercising habits.

As for DS, it is similar to gastric bypass, and to me it is a bit odd that your surgeon would mention DS out of all of the other WLS done today. DS is by far the rarest surgery for weight loss. In any case, you lose quicker with DS, but then there is the whole malabsorption to deal with.

In the end, all WLS work if you work with them. Maybe read up on DS and see if it is a surgery you'd be willing to live with.

If you want to talk to some DS'er's, you might find more info over at Obesityhelp.com in their DS forum.