Is thia cash ? no ins? if so i would contact some of the members on this site that has seen either of these Dr's. The are best to tell you about the doc and office "personality"- how they handle billing etc.. Also when your new patient appt happens if you are paying cash be sure to tell them you can't have any undisclosed prices from meds, labs needed everything. you always need to be prepared that the hospital / dr bills could change after the fact due to complications. If paying cash you will be required to pay everything upfront so that will be set. hope thuis helps.