I know the band has been a wonderful tool to many people. It just hasn't been a great tool for me, and I would like to have it removed. Has anyone else had their band removed? What was your experience?

Sorry your not happy. I am thrilled with my band. Best of luck to you.

I know the band has been a wonderful tool to many people. It just hasn't been a great tool for me, and I would like to have it removed. Has anyone else had their band removed? What was your experience?

What hasn't worked for you? Why do you want it removed?

This journey isn't always easy and we all lose at different paces, but even though I've been a slower loser I am so grateful for every pound. I also have had to deal with the frustrations and even discomfort at times but to me it's worth it. I wish you the best in your decision. Just make sure you consider it well and weight the pros and cons. I don't ever want to give my band up no matter what.

I am curious as to the problems you have encountered as well and what has caused you to decide to have it removed.

I got my band last April and have been very pleased with it. I have been losing the recommended 1-2 pounds per week since reaching restriction in July. I too have experienced the occasional discomfort, but nothing that would make me regret having the band.

I am so sorry that this is not working out for you.

I have several reasons for wanting to take the band out. I need to take Celebrex, which is not good for the band. I can barely get fluids down in the morning, much less any breakfast, because the band is too tight. I spend the rest of the day grazing because I am so hungry from not being able to eat in the morning. By noon I am usually OK, but not always. I could go on, but I really just want it out.

WHy don't you just get some fill or all of your fill taken out and then see how you feel?

I have only had one fill, and it was over a year ago. It made no difference.:cry I think physiologically I am just not meant to have the band. I'm not sad about it. Having it removed will just be inconvenient and expensive. Oh well.

If you thought it out and investigated all options and have decided the band is not for you, then you know best what's right for you. Good luck to you with the surgery and in your weight loss efforts.