Was anybody surprise who is out??

I thought for sure that Kevin was going to out. And that Kinik what going to stay?? Any surprises for you guys??

I thought Kevin was definetly out but he wont' make it to number 1 anyways he is so geeky. Chris is number 1 vocally. Michele or Mandisa or lisa for the girls. Who knows its lucky they made it this far. only time willl tell.

I had picked the following to be voted off:

Kinnick

Ayla

Will

Kevin

So, yeah, I was surprised that Gideon was voted off.

I'm happy for Kevin. He may be the token "geek" but he does have a decent voice. It takes guts to attempt a Josh Grobin song. I don't know how long he'll last though.

I think it's a shame that Gideon was voted off but Kevin stayed. Gideon is clearly the better singer. Usually my choices mesh with what happens, but this time they didn't. My choices for the winner are Mandisa, Paris, or Chris.

Was anybody surprise who is out??

I was rather surprised at Gedeon. I was nearly certain Kevin would go. Maybe the "cute" factor kept him alive this week. The only thing I can figure is that he's got some weird fan base out there that called like crazy.

The others were my picks to go. No surprises there.

I had guessed everyone correctly except Gedeon...he was a surprise to me, as I thought Kevin would go, too.

Emily

Was anybody surprise who is out??

I thought for sure that Kevin was going to out. And that Kinik what going to stay?? Any surprises for you guys??

Kevin (the baby faced darling of the girls) should have been gone last night, no questions asked. I think Gideon had a much superior voice. In the girls it should have been the other one that went home and not the tall girl. Just my opinion. It just depends on who calls in for who and who is getting the support.

I really like Kelly I hope she goes all the way!!!She seems so sweet and she is cute as a button!!

We have two American Idol threads, but looks like everyone has wandered over to the other one. It is getting longer and longer. Paula...how come you are laughing at me for listening to Fuel when "you know who they are" You listening in your spare time too?

I want Kevin to go....why do they think he is so good? I think Chris is awesome...and a hottie!! I want him to go all the way!

I want Kevin to go....why do they think he is so good? I think Chris is awesome...and a hottie!! I want him to go all the way!

You want him to go all the way...and my mind tells me you mean this in the purest form as in being the next American Idol :hat: Otherwise, I will have to e.mail Chris's wife and tell her you are totally into him. Wow, she sure is going to have her hands full if he wins...women love men that can sing!! Look at Clay Aiken, he's so homely he's cute and women just love him.

"I think Chris is awesome...and a hottie!! I want him to go all the way!"

I want him for that too!!!!

"I think Chris is awesome...and a hottie!! I want him to go all the way!"

I want him for that too!!!!

Ace in the bottom 3....unimaginable. What are people thinking??

Yea....I didn't agree with the bottom 3 at all. I did think Melissa would go, but Ace and Whats her name...uh...can't remember!..They are good. KEVIN NEEDS TO GO!!!! And yes......Chris can go all the way...well My husband might mind and his wife too...it will be our little secret..and ofcourse LBT!:teeth: