Question... Do the Premier Protein vanilla shakes taste like coconut to you? I think they taste a lot like Muscle Milk... Not vanilla flavored at me at all...just artificial coconut....(I quote the infamous Charlie Brown, "blech"!

No, they don't taste like coconut to me but they are way too sweet. I pour them over ice and add skim milk to cut the sweetness. Quest protein bars taste like coconut to me no matter what flavor they are supposed to be.

I haven't tried that brand, but many seem to taste like coconut. My favs are EAS AdvantEdge RTD shakes, and Designer whey-Chocolate, Vanilla almond and strawberry, (They do NOT taste like coconut) have yet to locate the chocolate caramel peanut butter but sounds delish!