With all the debating over gastric bypass vs. the Band, I still don't understand the difference between roux en y (sp?) vs Duodenal switch.

Which one of these causes some people to battle severe odor? Why does one have a pouch but the other doesn't, and which is which? I'm suddenly facisnated with the gastric bypass and must have info!

http://www.duodenalswitch.com/

Lots of info here on the DS for you.

http://www.angelfire.com/ok3/vbowen8/

This site goes over ALL of the WLS types & what & how it is done. What odor are you talking about? My sister-in-law had the RNY & her breath was foul for a few months but it passed. But vomits constantly & suffers from dumping syndrome. That's all I know!

Hi, Lisa. This compares the two in detail. It may be biased because it came from a DS site.

http://www.duodenalswitch.com/procedure/ds_vs__rny/ds_vs__rny.html

Lets see if this works: (Not the same as above link)

The BPD/DS combines restrictive and malabsorptive elements to achieve and maintain the best reported long-term percentage of excess weight loss among modern weight-loss surgery procedures. The Restrictive Component

The BPD/DS procedure includes a partial gastrectomy, which reduces the stomach along the greater curvature, effectively restricting its capacity while maintaining its normal functionality.

Unlike the unmodified BPD and RNY, which both employ a gastric “pouch” and bypass the pyloric valve, the DS procedure keeps the pyloric valve intact. This eliminates the possibility of dumping syndrome, marginal ulcers, stoma closures and blockages, all of which can occur after other gastric bypass procedures.

In addition, unlike the unmodified BPD and RNY procedures, the DS procedure keeps a portion of the duodenum in the food stream. The preservation of the pylorus/duodenum pathway means that food is digested normally (to an optimally absorbable consistency) in the stomach before being excreted by the pylorus into the small intestine. As a result, the DS procedure enables more-normal absorption of many nutrients (including Protein, Calcium, Iron and Vitamin B12) than is seen after other gastric bypass procedures.

The Malabsorptive Component

The malabsorptive component of the BPD/DS procedure rearranges the small intestine to separate the flow of food from the flow of bile and pancreatic juices. This inhibits the absorption of calories and some nutrients. Further down the digestive tract, these divided intestinal paths are rejoined; food and digestive juices begin to mix, and limited fat absorption occurs in the common tract as the food continues on its path toward the large intestine.

Here is RNY anatomy:

In the Sapala-Wood Micropouch® operation the very top of the stomach is completely divided. It is not stapled. This division results in the creation of a small “micropouch” completely separate from the lower part of the stomach. This Sapala-Wood Micropouch® is about the size of a grape (1-2 cc).

The small intestine is divided into two ends. One end travels upward to be connected to the Sapala-Wood Micropouch®.The other end is attached downward to the side of the distal small intestine to complete the circuit. Food travels down the esophagus, through the Sapala-Wood Micropouch®, to the intestine It bypasses the stomach. The bottom of the stomach no longer receives any food or liquids. But the stomach will still function because its nerve and blood supply are intact.

This is the best link, as it has info on all of the surgerys, not just RNY, DS and the AGB:

http://www.obesityhelp.com/morbidobesity/information/wlsjourney/surgery+types.php

That should help you out!

Rachele

Oh, I forgot. The DS is the one that is rumored to have "stinky Gas!"

The only time I have had it was when I had indulged in too much fat, which you shouldn't do anyway, no matter what surgery you have, or I ate something that typically gives you gas, like broccoli, Beans, cukes, you know...But when you get it, you can for sure clear a room!

It helps if you have a dog, because you can always blame them!

This thread got lost till now. Thanks for all the great info, especially the pictures.

As for the odor, I've heard and read about severe anal odor. Dr. Billy does bypass surgeries, so I've talked to some of his patients and his staff. The odor is associated with one version of the bypass, and it's so severe that Billy's staff can tell when a bypass patient walks in the door. Some are so severe that they wear carbon filters in their underwear to mask the smell.

However, I think the one that causes the odor is an old procedure, which is why I'm asking about the different types of bypass. Seems there's more than just 2 kinds, right? Since losing my band, I'm obsessed with bypass surgery just in case I start to gain my weight back. I'll have to post updated before & after pics to show you how scary I used to be.

I read an article the other day that said the DS was the most risky one!

Just cuz you are doing the research....there is also a procedure called Vertical Gastrectomy. My dr's office is REALLY high on this procedure, a lot of people have had it......from my dr's website:

http://www.lapsf.com/vertical-gastrectomy-weight-loss-surgery.php

The vertical gastrectomy sounds really interesting...but I'm sure it's not available in my area and I don't want to wait for ages until it is. But I am saving the info.

Emily

I read an article the other day that said the DS was the most risky one!

It is! But it offers the highest success rate, if you make it, that is!:confused:

http://www.obesityhelp.com/morbidobe...gery+types.php

There is info on that at this link, too. Actually I think that it has been around for quite a while. Don't quote me on that, though.

I'm not sure if that link is taking you to the right place. If it takes you to the home page click on wls types toward the left.

This thread got lost till now. Thanks for all the great info, especially the pictures.

As for the odor, I've heard and read about severe anal odor. Dr. Billy does bypass surgeries, so I've talked to some of his patients and his staff. The odor is associated with one version of the bypass, and it's so severe that Billy's staff can tell when a bypass patient walks in the door. Some are so severe that they wear carbon filters in their underwear to mask the smell.

However, I think the one that causes the odor is an old procedure, which is why I'm asking about the different types of bypass. Seems there's more than just 2 kinds, right? Since losing my band, I'm obsessed with bypass surgery just in case I start to gain my weight back. I'll have to post updated before & after pics to show you how scary I used to be.

Oh my gosh. No then, this is NOT the DS. EW. Carbon Filters? Yuck.

The DS surgery makes ppl stink:huytsao , but this can happen with RNY also and may have to do with severely reduced caloric intake--there are even some pills (brand name Devrom) that are sold as an "internal deodorant"

Is vertical gastrectomy the same as BPD/gastric sleeve?

I love all this info. Thanks!

calvin had RNY, he doesnt stink BUT HIS HINEY DOES!!! we buy LOTS of spray...luckily for me he is sweet and only 'lets one rip' in the bathroom, cause he knows he is leathal!!!!

hehehe luckily he doesnt read this site so he cant kill me for discussing his oder!