Ok so I have a slipped band, total unfill, no nausea or vomiting, and a hiatal hernia. I am on 40mg of prilosec twice a day. My surgeon doesnt see any immediate reason to do surgery, but he mentioned he will remove my band if thats what I wanted. My problem is a constant "lump" feeling in my throat that is uncomfortable & driving me insane! My upper GI & EGD also show no immediate reason for surgery but Im going crazy because of this lump feeling. Im to the point of just asking for a removal. Any advice or experiences? I was banded Dec 2006 & have the old 4cc band.

This is strictly my personal opinion, I'm no doctor or an expert. But, if it were me, I'd get it removed. The old 4cc bands are (unfortunately) notorious for slips and major problems. Chances are (again, unfortunately) that it's only going to get worse for you as time goes on. I'd prefer to get the problem resolved sooner than later.

If I were in your shoes and it was an option, I'd consider getting the 4cc band replaced with a newer bigger one. If I couldn't get a replacement, I'd consider getting the Sleeve.

Best wishes with whatever you decide.