Hi Kyle. I'm Erin and I was banded on Friday, Jan 21. My experience in getting approval was way easier than I expected and I will help you out in any way I can.
My PCP is Dr. Richard Funaro in Bay Ridge. He is a little gruff but every supportive of the lap band procedure....he actually suggested it to me and it took me 2 years to believe I couldn't do it myself.
I did a ton of research on hospitals and attended 4 info sessions and ultimately chose NYU Langone. My surgeon is Dr. Christine Ren and I think she hung the moon but others I know have seen Dr. Fielding and Dr. Kurian at NYU and said similar things. These people are rockstars!
Another great thing about NYU is that they have someone on staff to do the 6 month weight loss program for insurance approval. Her name is Dr. Stiles and I adore her. Each month, she told me how well I was doing and really used my six months as an opportunity to teach me how to eat after surgery. The best part is that she is technically a PCP herself so you pay the non-specialist co-pay for insurance, which is nice. You'll still need the support of your own PCP, however.
I cannot rave enough about NYU and their staff from the surgeons and Dr. Stiles to the psychiatrist they use.
This can be really frustrating but you are on the right track. Feel free to send me a personal message if you need a buddy. I also happen to work in insurance so I can decode their requirements if you get confused.
Best of luck,
Erin