Mexico Location's - Please Help

[I'm Changing 4 Me 8]

I will be a self pay in Mexico and I'm so overwhelmed with the different Drs and hospitals / centers.

I've researched so much it all seems to run together now !!! Can some sleever's please give me some recommendations on dr's and locations and why you chose them.. I wanna get this done like yesterday but can't get past the continual research mode !!!

NewMe

[VSGVega 26]

I will be a self pay in Mexico and I'm so overwhelmed with the different Drs and hospitals / centers.

I've researched so much it all seems to run together now !!! Can some sleever's please give me some recommendations on dr's and locations and why you chose them.. I wanna get this done like yesterday but can't get past the continual research mode !!!

NewMe

I'm going with Dr Luis Cervantes at hospital Guadalajara in Tijuana. I've verified his credentials and the hospital is a full hospital not a clinic. Big things that I've learned so far is, choose the hospital first,verify the surgeons and that they are board certified in bariatric surgery. I regret not trying to contact the surgeons or hospital directly instead of using a coordinator to save some wasted commission $. But I talked to one of the staff today about my preop plans and she answered my questions. I. Scheduled in March and I wish I could do it sooner. Don't use dr Almanza or altamarino cano. They have lots of bad publicity.

Sent from my QTAIR7 using the BariatricPal App

[I'm Changing 4 Me 8]

@@VSGVega thanks for your response! What do you mean wasted commissions? Does it cost to use a coordinator? Why couldn't you get ur surgery sooner if you want it sooner ?

[biginjapan 647]

@I'm Changing 4 Me

I created a spreadsheet to help me figure out what I wanted. Personally, I contacted each and every one of these companies/doctors. How are you going to know if you like them unless you deal with them directly? I think in reality, you have to go through some kind of coordinator. Do you expect your surgeon to be dealing with email and phone queries all day? (In fact, out of all these doctors, the only one I was in contact with was Dr. Illan - and while he seemed very nice, the wi-fi connection was so bad I have no idea if he actually answered any of my questions). So, while it would be nice to talk to them, it's not always possible. However, in some cases the coordinator will contact the doctor if you have any specific questions.

This is far from a full list, but based on this, and other sites, I felt that these were the most consistently well-regarded companies and surgeons. As I've mentioned in other posts, I think the biggest reason for price differences are the reputation of the doctor, the hospital used, and the hotels used.

Unless otherwise mentioned, all these doctors are in Tijuana, and these are quotes I got for a Gastric Sleeve (prices may vary depending on your personal health conditions):

Bariatric Pal Team MX: Dr. Jalil Illan ($4399)

Endo Bariatric (in Piedras Negras): Dr. Alvarez ($8900)

Mexico Bariatric Center: Dra. Louisiana Valenzuela ($5500) and Dr. Ismael Cabrera ($4995)

Obesity Control Center: Dr. Ariel Ortiz ($6500-$9000)

Pompeii Surgical: Dr. Sergio Quinones ($4500)

Ponce Bariatric: Dr. jaime ponce de leon ($5000)

Tijuana Bariatrics: Dr. Fernando Garcia ($4250)

WLSC: Dr. Ramos Kelly ($4870-$7710)

Another option seems to be Trinity Medical, also promoted by a pretty active member here, but unfortunately I didn't come across that company until after I had made my decision.

In my particular case, I live in Japan so unlike most of you in the US and Canada, I have some pretty long international flights, and my pear-shaped bottom can no longer squeeze into a 17" economy seat. I might have done that one-way, but I definitely did not want to be squeezed in for 14 hours after major abdominal surgery. Knowing that I would have to buy a business class seat on an international flight meant that I couldn't afford the more expensive doctors - so anything over $6000 was out. I did not like the way I was treated with Tijuana Bariatrics - all I got was a form letter "you've been approved - send money" - and all requests to speak to a coordinator or doctor were completely ignored. In the end the surgeons I was most interested in were Dr. Q, Dr. Ponce, and either Dr. Valenzuela or Dr. Cabrera at MBC. What swayed me the most was how well I was treated by the coordinator, and the amount of information they could give me about the operation, hospitals, etc, how many surgeries the doctor does daily (some doctors work out of more than one hospital, so make sure you find out the daily total and not the hospital total), and finally the price. Oh - and whether or not the surgery could be done on a day that was most convenient for me (for some reason it seems like a lot of the doctors will be away or on vacation or are already booked in February).

I know in the beginning it seems overwhelming, but the best thing to do is bookmark the sites you like, fill out the forms, and see what happens from there. I started with 3 different companies, but over time I expanded my search a little. That said, the problem is the paradox of choice: the more options we have, the more difficult it becomes to choose. Keep it small for now as you get your feet wet. Ask questions. Do research (other bariatric forums, Facebook, etc.) It should get better as you go along.

My surgery is less than 6 weeks away, so I can't tell you how it went, but I'm confident enough that I will be treated well. Anyway, I hope this helps.

Edited December 31, 2016 by biginjapan

[Dairymary 533]

I had my surgery with Dr. Ariel Ortiz at Obesity Control Center in Tijuana just over 6 years ago. My daughter is a gastroenterologist and he was specifically recommended to her by colleagues in the bariatric field. He was a world renown, cutting edge surgeon even then. I had a great experience, easy recovery and zero complications. As a nurse myself, I know the difference between quality healthcare and substandard, cut-rate care. Would recommend him and OCC to anyone interested in WLS.

[VSGVega 26]

When you use a Medical Tourism place, The deposit mostly goes to the coordinator as commission. If you research the hospital and the surgeons, you could just schedule directly with them. I do agree that I've found it helpful that the coordinator is available whenever I have questions. it's a personal choice and if I'd thought it through and did my research up front before paying the deposit, I may have scheduled directly but I'm okay with having the benefit of a coordinator. I'm self pay also so March is when I'll have the full amount. If I had the money now I'd schedule it for 2weeks. I'm so ready.

Sent from my QTAIR7 using the BariatricPal App

@@VSGVega thanks for your response! What do you mean wasted commissions? Does it cost to use a coordinator? Why couldn't you get ur surgery sooner if you want it sooner ?

[VSGVega 26]

@ biginjapan my research shows favorable results on the doctors you listed. Best of luck to you in your journey. Was Mexico the cheapest alternative for you? That's long travel time so be sure to get up frequently to walk. Did you discuss prevention of clots w your surgeon?

Sent from my QTAIR7 using the BariatricPal App

[Bon Appetit 41]

@@biginjapan did you consider Dr. Manuel Garcia Garza? I am starting research and am considering him. Thanks for your lengthy post it was very informative.

Sent from my SM-N920V using the BariatricPal App

[I'm Changing 4 Me 8]

@ biginjapan OMG you can't even imagine how much this has helped me and for some reason it soothed my soul ! I really appreciate your feedback and will use your advice to the fullest. Thanking you ever so much and good luck on your surgery and new beginnings!!

NewMe

[I'm Changing 4 Me 8]

@vsgega Ok that's great information. I was trying to figure that part out. This is very overwhelming and I greatly appreciate your feedback on this topic.

NewMe

[I'm Changing 4 Me 8]

@ Dairymary I have read good things about Dr Ortiz but wasn't sure which Ortiz it was as there are two in Mexico. Thanks for clearing that up for me

NewMe

[biginjapan 647]

@@biginjapan did you consider Dr. Manuel Garcia Garza? I am starting research and am considering him. Thanks for your lengthy post it was very informative.

Sent from my SM-N920V using the BariatricPal App

I didn't come across his name until after I made my decision. His credentials look great, though I'm a bit suspicious of the website he comes listed on. One, they deal with multiple doctors, instead of just one or two, which doesn't seem quite right to me (just my preference - I prefer going through sites that are dedicated to one or two doctors and the hospital they are connected to). Also, looking at some of the before and after photos - one of them lists a patient having lost 100 lbs in 2 months! Is that even possible?

However - I'm far from being an expert on anything!

[biginjapan 647]

@ biginjapan my research shows favorable results on the doctors you listed. Best of luck to you in your journey. Was Mexico the cheapest alternative for you? That's long travel time so be sure to get up frequently to walk. Did you discuss prevention of clots w your surgeon?

Sent from my QTAIR7 using the BariatricPal App

Thanks vsgvega!

As for Mexico, I had a few reasons to choose it over having the surgery done in Japan. First, although bariatric surgery is done in Japan, there are very few surgeons who specialise in it, which isn't surprising considering only 3.5% of the population is considered obese (at 30 BMI). My experience with Japanese doctors isn't very positive - they rarely tell you anything, and you have to push for more information. For example, my cholesterol is kind of high, but most doctors I go to tell me "not to worry about it." I sometimes have pain/pressure that feels like a hernia in my stomach area, but when I expressed my concern about it to my gastroenterologist, he told me to eat less (while tracing over my breasts where the stomach was - not appropriate!). I had minor surgery just over a year ago, and while the surgery results were fine, the post-op experience in the hospital was not. Also, Asian people (in general) are more sensitive to pain medication than non-Asians, so the meds here are not very strong. For pain killers, we are often given the equivalent of baby aspirin (I had that after surgery, so did a friend of mine who had a C-section). OTC meds, like Tylenol, are much stronger and more effective than anything they give me here (which I have to import, since they don't sell it here, or if they do it's hard to find - a former doctor of mine always brings some back with him after he goes to Europe, since even as a doctor, he can't get it here). Some suffering is expected at all times - I feel bad for patients with chronic diseases who are in constant pain because the doctors here won't give them anything stronger.

Another reason is insurance - with insurance it probably would have cost me at least $7000, without it, at least $25,000. So the cost of my surgery + the flight will be slightly more than if I had stayed in Japan (with insurance). But even if my insurance covered it, I would be reluctant to have the surgery since nothing is private here - since health insurance is provided by the company you work for, they know everything about you. We do health checks every year, and the company gets those results. Any operations or other procedures I get done - they know about it. The lack of privacy here is appalling, and for years I refused to do the health checks for that reason, but they're free and worth the information I get from them. But I'm keeping this surgery secret (for now) - I want to be the one who determines who knows about it.

So basically I'm going to Mexico because I want to deal with people who speak English, have a surgeon who has loads of experience, keep the surgery private, and also because, by flying to the States, I can also pick up some items I will need post-op that I can't get here in Japan. Every doctor I asked did not seem concerned about flying post-op, and I will have compression stockings and will walk around a lot (easier in business class too). I will also stay in San Diego for 4 days after I am released, so I will be flying back to Japan a week after surgery, which I think will help with pain or other issues. I'm travelling by myself but I think I will be able to get help with my suitcase every step of the way (hotel, cab, airport).

Anyway, sorry for the long post - it was much longer than I expected it to be!

[biginjapan 647]

@ biginjapan OMG you can't even imagine how much this has helped me and for some reason it soothed my soul ! I really appreciate your feedback and will use your advice to the fullest. Thanking you ever so much and good luck on your surgery and new beginnings!!

NewMe

You're welcome! Actually, I had the same feelings you did when I first started 6 months ago, and I felt frustrated with the "do your own research" but that nobody had actually got down to specifics with real information. I'm glad this helps you, and I hope it helps other people researching WLS in Mexico (although I imagine the costs will date themselves soon enough). Let us know who you eventually go with! (FWIW, I'm going with Dr. Cabrera).

[biginjapan 647]

I had my surgery with Dr. Ariel Ortiz at Obesity Control Center in Tijuana just over 6 years ago. My daughter is a gastroenterologist and he was specifically recommended to her by colleagues in the bariatric field. He was a world renown, cutting edge surgeon even then. I had a great experience, easy recovery and zero complications. As a nurse myself, I know the difference between quality healthcare and substandard, cut-rate care. Would recommend him and OCC to anyone interested in WLS.

@Dairymary: Dr. Ortiz was at the top of my list for a long while, but financially I just couldn't afford him, so had to go with a slightly less expensive doctor. I've heard nothing but good things about him across all the different forums.